Deputy Secretary for Justice Horace Cheung reassured the public that Hong Kong’s rule of law and legal system remain strong despite another overseas judge stepping down from the SAR’s top court. Nicholas Phillips, a British non-permanent judge, recently resigned, marking the fifth departure of an overseas non-permanent judge this year.
During an interview on an RTHK radio programme, Cheung acknowledged that some overseas judges may be experiencing political pressure from their home countries, while others may be leaving for personal reasons. He emphasized that the presence of overseas judges in Hong Kong is unique to the system but is not a definitive factor in determining the quality of the rule of law.
Cheung highlighted that many overseas judges, both current and former, have praised Hong Kong’s rule of law and legal system. He urged the public to have confidence in the local judiciary despite the resignations of overseas judges. Additionally, he mentioned that efforts are ongoing to recruit new overseas judges from various countries to maintain diversity and expertise within the court.
In response to criticisms from foreign politicians regarding Hong Kong’s rule of law, Cheung emphasized the importance of not allowing external influences to undermine the integrity of the legal system. He called for unity in upholding the reputation and effectiveness of Hong Kong’s judiciary.
It is essential for the public to trust in the resilience and independence of Hong Kong’s legal institutions. The departure of overseas judges should not be seen as a weakening of the rule of law but rather as a natural transition in the judicial system. By continuing to uphold the principles of justice and fairness, Hong Kong can maintain its reputation as a global legal hub.
