Putting Anne Hathaway in a romantic comedy is like having a secret weapon. Her infectious energy and charm create a chemistry that is simply electric. While she may be known for her bubbly public persona, her body of work showcases a depth and versatility that is truly remarkable. With her musical theater background, Hathaway brings a unique blend of energy to her performances, drawing from a well of emotional depth that adds layers and dimensionality to her characters. In Michael Showalter’s film, “The Idea of You,” Hathaway shines in a role that challenges the toxic clichés of the romantic comedy genre.
The film follows Solène (played by Hathaway), a 39-year-old art gallery owner and divorced mother to 16-year-old Izzy (Ella Rubin). When she unexpectedly finds herself chaperoning Izzy and her friends to Coachella, she meets Hayes Campbell (Nick Galitzine), a 24-year-old member of the boy band August Moon. The age difference between Solène and Hayes sets the stage for a unique and refreshing take on the classic rom-com formula.
The Realism of Romance
While “The Idea of You” maintains a reasonable proximity to realist logic, it does not shy away from incorporating elements of fantasy inherent in the romantic comedy genre. The meet-cute between Solène and Hayes, for example, is a prime example of this blend of reality and fantasy. In a world where encounters like theirs rarely happen outside of scripted settings, the film takes a creative approach to bringing them together. Solène mistaking Hayes’s trailer for a restroom sets the stage for a series of events that challenge the expectations of both characters and audiences alike.
As Solène and Hayes navigate their budding relationship, the film explores the complexities of their connection with a refreshing honesty. Solène’s confrontation of Hayes’s intentions when he buys every piece in her gallery speaks to her character’s strength and agency. Their interactions are nuanced and realistic, showcasing the challenges and joys of getting to know someone in an unconventional situation.
A Match Made in Rom-Com Heaven
The pairing of Solène and Hayes is a study in contrasts that ultimately complements each other in unexpected ways. Solène’s intelligence, cultural sophistication, and independence are juxtaposed with Hayes’s fame, youth, and talent. This dynamic creates a tension that drives the narrative forward, challenging both characters to confront their preconceived notions of love and relationships.
Throughout the film, Solène and Hayes engage in conversations that reveal their vulnerabilities and insecurities, underscoring the universal experience of navigating new relationships. Their hesitance to fully open up to each other reflects the complexities of human connection, showcasing the authenticity of their interactions.
A Thoughtful Exploration of Love and Fantasy
“The Idea of You” delves into the escapist fantasy inherent in romantic comedies while grounding the narrative in the emotional realities of its characters. The film’s formal innovations, such as split diopter shots and head-on mid-length shots, offer unique perspectives on the characters’ experiences, inviting audiences to step into their shoes.
As the story unfolds, Solène’s journey takes center stage, offering a poignant exploration of her personal growth and self-discovery. Hathaway’s powerhouse performance in a monologue about Solène’s divorce highlights the emotional depth and complexity of her character, setting the stage for a compelling narrative arc.
In conclusion, “The Idea of You” is a refreshing take on the romantic comedy genre that challenges conventions and offers a thoughtful exploration of love, fantasy, and human connection. Hathaway’s magnetic performance, coupled with the film’s innovative storytelling techniques, makes it a must-watch for fans of the genre and newcomers alike. As Solène and Hayes navigate the complexities of their relationship, audiences are treated to a heartfelt and genuine portrayal of love in all its messy, beautiful glory.